Fay Ranches represented the seller in the off-market sale of Stagecoach Lake Ranch, a magnificent property of 308± acres overlooking Stagecoach Lake. It lies only 13± miles south of Steamboat Springs and adjacent to Discovery Land Company’s proposed Stagecoach Ranch Ski Development. This ranch included 50± acre-feet of Overman Reservoir water right and the perfect blend of open meadow and forested areas. The original homestead cabin and outbuildings offer a glimpse into the ranch’s past and a view of four designated wilderness areas. The property is unencumbered by conservation easement and offers exceptional homesites, including future limited development opportunities. As a representative of the sale price, this ranch is unique in the overall land marketplace.
Special properties deserve an exceptional land brokerage company like Fay Ranches. Our team has the knowledge, proven record of success, and a deep appreciation for the land and its traditions. We know how to market your unique property to the right audience. We invite you to learn more about our approach. Please call us at 800-238-8616 or click on the link below for more information.
Learn More
Spanning acres of Colorado short-grass prairie, this ranch offers one of the most resilient and productive grazing ecosystems in the West. Historically operated as a cow/calf operation and recently leased for yearlings, it demonstrates strong versatility. The property is fully fenced with four dependable wells, efficient working corrals, and a scale. A 1,680± square foot home and multiple outbuildings combine comfort, functionality, and proven ranching infrastructure.
This expansive eastern Colorado ranch combines the productivity of shortgrass prairie with the rugged beauty of rolling sandhills. Native vegetation creates durable forage well-suited to semi-arid conditions. Fully fenced and cross-fenced, it supports rotational grazing with six solar-powered wells and a large catch pond. Long managed for cow/calf and yearling operations, it offers reliable water, proven efficiency, and ecological integrity for sustainable livestock production.
This exceptional irrigated farm and feed yard includes a four-bedroom, two-bath home with a wrap-around porch and finished basement. Ideal for cattle and hay operations, it features an 800-head feedlot, roping arena, tack shed, irrigated grass trap, grain bins, a new hay shed, calving barn, scale, and 2,040± square foot shop. The farm produces high-quality alfalfa and grass hay with extensive water rights and infrastructure, offering a rare blend of production and livability.
Located in Northwest Colorado’s prime elk migratory corridor, this diverse recreational property offers timber, meadows, ponds, and springs with adjudicated water rights. A custom barn includes a heated shop, kitchen, and private living quarters. Stocked ponds, big game habitat, and nearby USFS access make it ideal for hunting and family recreation. Trails lead to Steamboat Lake and beyond. Designed with care, it’s a fully developed, turnkey retreat built for lasting family memories.
In Colorado’s North Park, this income-producing ranch offers rare ownership of a contiguous, heavily watered operation with senior water rights and premium bison infrastructure. It includes three well-situated homes, robust hay production, and adjudicated ditches dating to the 1880s. Founded in 1882 and refined by conservation-minded stewardship, the ranch blends agricultural capability, recreation, and lasting value—ideal for buyers seeking meaningful land ownership in the American West.
This premier homesite is located in Steamboat Springs’ South Valley and offers 360-degree views of Lake Catamount, conserved ranchland, and National Forest. As the first lot was chosen in the original selection, it reflects an unmatched location and scenery. Set within a gated community with a 3.3± acre building envelope, it provides privacy, direct trail access, and the option to join the Catamount Ranch & Club, featuring a private lake, golf, Nordic skiing, and top-tier recreational amenities.
Situated at the base of the West Spanish Peak and adjacent to the Big Wall, this Colorado property lies in a prime wildlife corridor for elk. It’s part of a private subdivision known for dark skies and quiet surroundings in GMU 85, where elk tags are over the counter. A 2,552± SF home features panoramic views, hardwood floors, a fireplace, and patios. With recent additions, it’s flexible for up to four bedrooms. Horse-friendly and close to La Veta’s amenities, this is a rare opportunity.
Offered for the first time in nearly 30 years, this productive hay and livestock operation spans two irrigated farms with senior water rights, Zimmatic pivots, ponds, and transferable irrigation. Producing high-yield alfalfa and grass hay, it includes valuable shares in Catlin, Otero, and Larkspur canals, strong road access, and established infrastructure. With consistent production, quality water sources, and crop base, it offers long-term agricultural viability and income potential.
Mountain Star Ranch near Guffey offers a secluded 5-bed, 6,500± SF log home in a Rocky Mountain valley. Accessible by a private mile-long drive, the home features Montana pine logs, vaulted ceilings, floor-to-ceiling windows, stained glass, and an indoor pond with a waterfall. The ranch includes a renowned horse barn, large garages, and a versatile workshop. Bordering 16,000± acres of BLM land, it offers prime hunting and two LOP Draw applications. Located near Breckenridge & Colorado Springs.
Surrounded by conserved ranches, this property is ideal for a hunting retreat or private ranch development. It features attractive home sites, small agriculture potential, and topography favorable for big game. The land includes grasslands, creek bottoms, and timbered areas, with water rights and scenic rock outcroppings. Accessed via two private gated entrances, it offers exceptional privacy and a diverse ecosystem, including elk, mule deer, and other wildlife, making it a unique opportunity.
This land supports various species, including mule deer, elk, pronghorn, bighorn sheep, coyotes, and mountain lions. It is a blend of grazing land and diverse wildlife habitat in southeastern Colorado. Cattle grazing and hunting leases with potential landowner tags enhance the land’s value. Adjacent to the Apishapa State Wildlife Area, it enriches hunting prospects. A solar-powered water well ensures sufficient water for livestock and wildlife amid rugged canyons and native grasslands.
Just west of Steamboat Springs, Colorado, the Doc Utterback Ranch spans 1,634± deeded acres and 640± leased acres. This mountain ranch features varied topography, from open meadows to forests and riparian zones along Tow & Little Tow Creeks. It offers rich big game hunting opportunities, with mule deer, elk, bear, and a recently spotted moose. Awarded for its habitat restoration, the ranch includes 9 springs and is fully fenced with big game-friendly wire, ideal for conservation-focused buyers.
Approaching the gated entrance, encounter a picturesque Eden-like setting featuring Smith Fork Creek, a fishing pond, a vineyard, equestrian facilities, and rustic cabins framed by a private canyon backdrop. Abundant wildlife thrives thanks to substantial water rights & a flexible conservation easement, offering additional building and subdivision potential. Canyon Ranch sprawls across 663± acres in central-western Colorado, with access to BLM trails near Black Canyon of Gunnison National Park.
This Colorado ranch boasts a 7,200± square foot custom luxury home with four bedroom suites and a dry sauna. It offers year-round access, a 4± acre lake, exceptional elk and mule deer hunting, water and mineral rights, and access to public lands. With grid-tied solar power, redundant systems like two boilers and septic systems, plus a 15kW backup generator, it ensures efficiency and reliability. This property combines luxury living with recreational opportunities only minutes from La Veta.
Yampa Headwaters Ranch in Colorado features a unique Army Corps-permitted wetland mitigation bank with over 200 credits, two creeks, and multiple stocked ponds. The ranch includes a 100+ acre hay meadow, wetland areas, and diverse upland topography. It offers fishing in Brinker and Chimney Creeks, stocked ponds, and abundant waterfowl. Improvements include a custom barn with an apartment. Its wetland credits and recreational assets make it a unique investment opportunity.
Zoe’s Ranch is established in a stunning setting in Colorado, with mature trees for privacy and shade and a seasonal creek. The views and the ranch’s terrain are hard to beat, with Greenhorn Mountain standing proudly to the west. The property has well-established landscaping, enhancing the beauty of the setting. The thoughtfully designed improvements are ideal for someone who wants a turn-key horse property and a well-appointed home that is already finished and ready to be enjoyed.
This Colorado ranch offers much: 1.5± miles of productive fish habitat-improved Lake Fork Creek, water rights, hunting opportunities, stunning views, easy access to world-class ski areas, the summer jaunt over Independence Pass to Aspen, and recreational opportunities. A golf course, fish hatchery, Turquoise Lake, and the Arkansas River are all neighbors. Whatever draws you to consider this ranch, it is not difficult to see all the possibilities and wonderful attributes that are Lake Fork Ranch.
IMN Heaven Ranch is aptly named if you value abundant wildlife, the privacy of a large acreage property, excellent big game hunting, productive water well, expansive, beautiful views, a seasonally mild climate, and easy year-round access in southern Colorado. Hunt elk and mule deer on your own property with private access to a large landlocked 2,000+ acre Bureau of Land Management (BLM) parcel. IMN Heaven remains a blank slate with water, electricity, and a workshop already in place.
Unique and exceptional fly fishing and recreational property in southern Colorado boasts 2 miles of Culebra Creek, home to giant wild brown and cutbow trout. Surrounded by 14,000-foot mountain peaks, the views are stunning. The property realizes income through a fishing club lease, which interferes very little with the use of the property by the owner. The purchase comes with a Solitary Angler’s Fishing membership, allowing access to over 25 miles of prime fishing waters in CO, NM, and WY.
