PROPERTY FACTS PHOTOS MAP SHARE INQUIRE

Nestled in the heart of Nye, Montana, Stillwater Legacy Ranch is a rare and remarkable offering that is rich in history and epitomizes the beauty and recreational abundance of the Stillwater Valley. Encompassing approximately 712± deeded acres, this property is framed by nature’s finest elements—rugged peaks, winding rivers, fertile meadows, and expansive nearby public lands. A true sanctuary for outdoor enthusiasts and nature lovers, the ranch is surrounded by the stunning Beartooth Mountains and Absaroka-Beartooth Wilderness. This untouched backcountry yields access to world-class hiking, fishing, hunting, and outdoor adventure, right from your back gate and beyond.

Stillwater Legacy Ranch boasts an extraordinary 1.65± miles of the Stillwater River frontage, complemented by 0.7± miles of both sides of the West Fork Stillwater River flowing through the middle of the property. In addition to these significant water features, the property hosts a network of spring creeks that offer outstanding potential for stream restoration and enhancement, creating both ecological value and fly-fishing opportunities. Adding to its rarity, these natural thermal springs that never freeze over flow year-round through the property, enhancing its appeal, utility, and natural wonder.

Originally homesteaded in 1896, this working ranch has been owned and operated by the same family for 129 years. It has earned distinction as a Montana Historical Ranch and is a treasured part of the state’s ranching heritage.

Agriculturally, the ranch offers a strong and well-balanced operation, featuring 208± acres of irrigated ground and an additional 200± acres of sub-irrigated ground, with ample hay production and the capacity to support a thriving cattle operation through both private and permitted grazing resources. Improvements on the property include three modest homes, a barn, a garage, and four sheds—ideal for supporting an active agricultural lifestyle.

Stillwater Legacy Ranch is ideally situated just 45± minutes from Columbus, 1± hour from the charming town of Red Lodge, and 1.5± hours from the commercial hub of Billings. Whether you’re seeking a private retreat, a working ranch, or a family legacy property, Stillwater Legacy Ranch offers unmatched natural beauty, abundant flowing waters, historic prestige, and remarkable privacy.

PROPERTY FACTS:

  • 712± deeded acres
  • 1.65± miles of Stillwater River and 0.7± miles of both sides of the West Fork Stillwater River – crystal-clear trout water and endless natural beauty
  • Thermal waters and natural springs flow throughout the ranch, with opportunities for stream restoration
  • With no zoning restrictions and no conservation easement, you are free to build, preserve, or evolve the land as you see fit
  • Abundant wildlife including whitetail deer, wild turkeys, waterfowl, bears, mountain lions, and bald eagles
  • Surrounded by the stunning Absaroka-Beartooth Wilderness – close access to world-class hiking, fishing, hunting, and outdoor adventure
  • ATV access to high mountain lakes and scenic forest trails
  • 208± acres of irrigated creeping meadow foxtail and orchard grass, plus 200± acres of sub-irrigated ground
  • Supports 160 cow/calf from October through May, with 12 bulls and 30 replacement heifers on summer lease ground, plus a forest service permit for 39 head from July 25 through September 30
  • Just minutes to Woodbine Falls and a Custer National Forest trailhead, located within 5± miles
  • 20± air miles from Yellowstone National Park
  • 45± minutes from Columbus, Montana, 1± hour from Red Lodge, and 1.5± hours from Billings and Billings Logan International Airport
  • Learn more about this property, its investment potential and information about the area in the Property Brochure.

Our Reach

Special properties deserve an exceptional land brokerage company like Fay Ranches. Our team has the knowledge, proven record of success, and a deep appreciation for the land and its traditions. We know how to market your unique property to the right audience. We invite you to learn more about our approach. Please call us at 800-238-8616 or click on the link below for more information.

Learn More

Similar Properties

montana property for sale lolo creek shadows
New Listing

Lolo Peak Shadows

Lolo, Montana

This property borders the Lolo National Forest and includes deeded land across five parcels with diverse terrain—forests, ridgelines, meadows, and creeks. It has panoramic build sites, a road network, and off-grid infrastructure. On-site recreation includes hunting, skiing, hiking, and wildlife viewing, with direct access to vast public land. Just 10± miles from Lolo and 21± from Missoula, this unencumbered Montana property offers privacy, access, and potential for investment or recreation.

  • $6,900,000
  • 1,882± Acres
montana fly fishing property for sale linehan outfitting
New Listing

Linehan Outfitting

Libby, Montana

Near the town of Libby, in a pristine and less-discovered area of Montana rich with fish and wildlife, Linehan Outfitting operates from their Kootenai River Lodge along the Kootenai River. The lodge serves as the perfect launch point for guests, who can relax and enjoy the sights and sounds of the river between their hunting and fishing adventures. Linehan Outfitting is one of the few businesses in the industry offering a full range of hunting and fishing packages year-round. 

  • $3,600,000
  • 8± Acres
montana fly fishing property for sale big hole river cabin
New Listing

Big Hole River Cabin

Wise River, Montana

At the base of the Dickie Hills with views of the Pioneer Mountains, this property boasts 500± feet of Big Hole River frontage. A 1,984± SF home sits steps from the river. This area is home to elk, deer, moose, bear, ducks, and more. The property is just 5± minutes from Wise River and its airstrip, and less than an hour from Butte’s commercial airport, offering the perfect balance of seclusion and accessibility. Whether you’re seeking fishing, adventure, or serenity, this retreat has it all.

  • $1,395,000
  • 10± Acres
montana home for sale peacemaker ridge at the ranches at belt creek
New Listing

Peacemaker Ridge at The Ranches at Belt Creek

Belt, Montana

This Montana property boasts 18± acres of deeded land in a private recreational community. As an owner and member of the Ranches at Belt Creek, fishing opportunities are ample, with Belt Creek traversing through the community for 8± miles and the famous Missouri River just minutes away. Luxurious and secluded, a lifetime of possibilities is just outside your back door. This property is the ultimate find for those who want it all waiting for them when they drive through the gate.

  • $3,300,000
  • 18± Acres
montana ranch for sale three ranges ranch
New Listing

Three Ranges Ranch

Roberts, Montana

This Montana property offers panoramic views of the Beartooth, Pryor, and Crazy Mountains and lies just 15± minutes from Red Lodge. With dryland hay ground, rolling hills, a seasonal creek, and a spring-fed reservoir, it supports livestock or hay production. The owner plans to add electricity and a well. Accessed by two county roads, the land borders State Land and hosts elk, mule deer, and upland birds. Surrounded by renowned recreation, it’s ideal for building, ranching, or outdoor pursuits.

  • $850,000
  • 264± Acres
montana land for sale bangtail creek ranch
New Listing

Bangtail Creek Ranch

Livingston, Montana

Most of this acreage is contiguous to National Forest, near Livingston, Bozeman, the Yellowstone River, and Yellowstone National Park. The land boasts views of the Crazy Mountains, Bangtail Ridge, and the Chief Mountain plateau. Wildlife roam through the sage-filled land with newly constructed roads and electricity. This is the ideal location to build your dream home in Montana, as you can enjoy the seclusion of your private property with the convenience of nearby amenities.

  • $10,654,000
  • 1,522± Acres
montana ranches for sale sheep mountain high point ranch
New Listing

Sheep Mountain High Point Ranch

Red Lodge, Montana

A stunning five-bedroom, 5.5-bath custom home near Red Lodge, “Luther”, Montana, sits privately at the end of the road, surrounded by State Land and National Forest on three sides. Crafted with reclaimed materials and local stone, the property includes a horse barn, complete guest quarters, and direct access to hunting, fishing, and horseback riding on public lands. Wildlife is abundant, views are protected, and recreation opportunities extend all the way to Yellowstone National Park.

  • $5,900,000
  • 26± Acres
montana home for sale highland ranch
New Listing

Highland Ranch

Livingston, Montana

Between the vibrant mountain towns of Bozeman and Livingston, Highland Ranch sits in one of Montana’s most coveted recreational corridors. The property boasts awe-inspiring views of four mountain ranges—Crazy, Absaroka, Gallatin, and Bridger—framing every sunrise and sunset. From the expansive porches of the custom 4,111± square foot, three-bed, three and a half-bath home, watch elk graze, and golden light paint the peaks—this is mountain living at its most majestic.

  • $3,495,000
  • 41± Acres
Montana ranches for sale Austin Meadows Mountain Ranch
New Listing

Austin Meadows Mountain Ranch

Helena, Montana

Just west of Helena, Montana, this rare opportunity offers a balance of seclusion, scenery, and access to town. Surrounded by the Rocky Mountains and bordering National Forest, the land features a seasonal creek, lush riparian zones, & abundant wildlife including elk, deer, and moose. With no improvements, it’s a blank canvas for a custom home or retreat. Panoramic views, quiet surroundings, and proximity to medical care, shopping, dining, & a regional airport make this an exceptional offering.

  • $1,725,000
  • 197± Acres
montana ranch for sale cottonwood ranch on the yellowstone
New Listing

Cottonwood Ranch on the Yellowstone

Columbus, Montana

Nestled along a scenic stretch of the Yellowstone River near Columbus, Montana, this rare opportunity offers river frontage, cottonwood bottomlands, and productive pasture. Wildlife thrives in this unspoiled setting, from whitetail deer and wild turkeys to pheasants and elk. With elevated building sites outside the floodplain and easy year-round access, the property blends natural beauty, recreation, and agricultural value just 45 minutes from Billings.

  • $3,300,000
  • 441± Acres
montana land for sale springhill 40
New Listing

Springhill 40

Bozeman, Montana

Secluded and located in the shadow of Ross Peak, this property is in a vibrant and varied wildlife corridor near the Springhill community. Tom Reese Creek and Evan Reese Creek turn into Reese Creek, flowing through the property for about a third of a mile. Just 25± minutes north of Bozeman, this private escape is the epitome of scenic beauty. The acreage is comprised of lush wetlands and groves of aspens with exquisite views of the south face of the Bridger Mountains and Gallatin Valley.

  • $2,700,000
  • 40± Acres
montana ranches for sale East Glacier View Ranch
New Listing

East Glacier View Ranch

East Glacier park, Montana

This exceptional riverfront property near East Glacier Park offers direct frontage on the Two Medicine River with sweeping views of Glacier National Park. Rolling terrain, meadows, and wooded bottoms provide an ideal setting for a custom home or retreat. Enjoy year-round access, nearby amenities, and unmatched recreation—fly fishing, horseback riding, hiking, and skiing. With its natural resources and location, it’s well suited for conservation, investment, or a private escape.

  • $1,400,000
  • 163± Acres
montana fishing property for sale flying c ranch
New Listing

Flying C Ranch

Nye, Montana

This Montana ranch spans 11,177± acres, of which 8,880± are deeded, supporting populations of elk, deer, mountain lions, upland birds, antelope, and black bears. Roughly 3.5 miles of the ranch borders National Forest, which transitions into Absaroka-Beartooth Wilderness and Yellowstone National Park. In addition to 620± acres of contiguous State Land and 1,677± acres of contiguous BLM land, the property enjoys 1.4± miles of pristine Stillwater River frontage for trout fishing.

  • $18,300,000
  • 8,880± Acres
montana ranch for sale snowberry springs
New Listing

Snowberry Springs

Lincoln, Montana

Located in Montana’s Upper Blackfoot Valley, this property offers rare access to wildlife, multiple creeks, and prime elk habitat. A restored stream enhances its conservation value, while a nearby national forest provides endless recreation. The protected viewshed includes the Scapegoat Wilderness, with a scenic build site near Stonewall Creek. Just outside Lincoln and close to Helena, Missoula, and Great Falls, this retreat balances solitude, access, and ecological significance.

  • $1,100,000
  • 158± Acres
montana ranch for sale mjs ranch
New Listing

MJS Ranch

Cameron, Montana

Nestled in Montana’s breathtaking Madison Valley near Cameron, this secluded end-of-the-road ranch is bordered by 2.5± miles of National Forest, offering direct access to pristine wilderness. Enjoy sweeping mountain views, abundant wildlife, two year-round creeks, and close proximity to the world-renowned Madison River for fly fishing. Improvements include a custom main home, guest cabin, indoor riding arena, barns, and full ranch infrastructure—ideal for cattle, horses, recreation, and retreat.

  • $12,900,000
  • 1,416± Acres
montana fishing property for sale moose landing on the gallatin river
New Listing

Moose Landing on the Gallatin River

Big Sky, Montana

Step out your back door and stroll down to your private 200± feet of Gallatin River frontage. Just minutes from Big Sky Town Center and a 15± minute drive to world-class skiing at Big Sky Resort, this 3,918± square foot home offers five bedrooms and ample space. Nestled on 3.6± acres, this is a dream retreat for families who love skiing, hiking, golfing, fishing, and exploring. Gather in the cozy great room, enjoy views of Gallatin National Forest, and make unforgettable memories year-round.

  • $3,950,000
  • 3± Acres
montana ranch for sale montana river retreat
New Listing

Montana River Retreat

McLeod, Montana

This Montana retreat features rare Boulder River frontage, four spring-fed ponds, and a winding spring creek, creating an exceptional fishing opportunities. The custom mountain modern home was designed to maximize views and blend indoor comfort with outdoor beauty. Set in the scenic Boulder River Valley, it offers unmatched fly fishing, abundant wildlife, and peaceful seclusion, all within close reach of Big Timber and just over an hour from the vibrant community and amenities of Bozeman.

  • $5,795,000
  • 68± Acres
montana home for sale nordic escape by the yellowstone
New Listing

Nordic Escape by the Yellowstone

Livingston, Montana

Just 10± minutes from Livingston, Montana, this property includes views of the Yellowstone River, Mission Creek, Sheep Mountain, and the Absaroka, Gallatin, and Beartooth Mountain Ranges. The 1,536± SF, 4 bed, 2 bath custom home boasts an open concept, energy efficiency, and attention to detail. Just a half mile away, access the Yellowstone River for trout fishing at Sheep Mountain FWP. The property enjoys shared ownership and exclusive access to an 89± acre island on the Yellowstone River.

  • $1,090,000
  • 4± Acres
montana water frontage for sale big flat river ranch
New Listing

Big Flat River Ranch

Missoula, Montana

This riverfront property offers approximately 1,800 feet of Clark Fork River frontage, combining agricultural use, recreation, and proximity to Missoula. A 2,496± square foot home features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and rustic finishes. The level, irrigated land includes 26± acres of hay ground, extensive water rights, and horse-ready infrastructure. Adjacent Forest Service land expands recreation access. This is a rare opportunity for riverfront living just minutes from downtown Missoula.

  • $2,000,000
  • 64± Acres
montana horse property for sale castle butte ranch

Casino Creek Ranch

Lewistown, Montana

Just minutes from Lewistown, Montana, this property features a home, horse barn, and heated shop. The horse barn includes ample space for stalling, tack storage, and feed. Adjacent pastures offer room to roam, and the property’s live water ensures reliable year-round hydration for animals. A large heated shop is attached to a dog kennel with heated floors and its own septic. With views of the Judith Mountains and live water running through, this acreage offers utility and inspiration.

  • $2,700,000
  • 75± Acres
montana ranch for sale jefferson river preserve

Jefferson River Preserve

Three Forks, Montana

This riverfront property in Montana features fertile bottomland, spring-fed wetlands, and vibrant wildlife habitat. Towering cottonwoods, meandering sloughs, and abundant waterfowl, upland birds, and big game create an unmatched recreational retreat. With an existing home and a ready-to-build homesite, this scenic escape offers privacy, flexibility, and stunning views of surrounding mountain ranges—just a short drive from modern conveniences.

  • $5,500,000
  • 250± Acres