Determining Ranch Value
A blog by Jerry Hicks, Fay Ranches Principal Broker
Each ranch is as unique as a fingerprint. Acreage, live waters (rivers, creeks, lakes), Timberland, farm ground, location, efficiency, aesthetics, irrigation, recreational assets, and timing are just a few of the dimensions that come together to determine value! These are just some of the characteristics one must consider when assessing a ranch or farm property. Experience tells me that one must peel away the layers when looking at “similar” ranches. Just like judging livestock or a beauty contestant, we must bracket the differences and similarities in each ranch, placing them in an order that is usually supported by recent sales. Once comparable sales determine the value, we then begin to see where the ranch would be considered a competitive and compelling choice, based on the value within the field of other properties on the market. It’s very easy for a seller to have high expectations and listing prices based on similar overpriced properties currently on the market. The harder but more beneficial conversation we have with our sellers involves what the ranch offers and how that fits in the current market, based on recent sales.
As a buyer, one should spend a great deal of time in the due diligence period to fairly assess value on a ranch, and most importantly, to make sure you are satisfied with your potential investment. Comparable ranches are never a mirror image of each other. To use the most common formula (a per acre value) is like saying all 25-year-old men are in excellent health, which we know is untrue. While using a price per acreage value is a good starting point, one must evaluate production and carrying capacity and have an understanding of secondary value such as hunting and fishing opportunities, location, and climate. Third level benefits to assess and consider would include timber, mineral opportunities, and development credits. Are the improvements helping the value or causing buyers to be reluctant to assume someone else’s dream as possibly their new nightmare? (This phenomenon is called functional obsoleteness.) If we could only see things through the eye of the buyer, rather than the emotional view of a seller, value would be much easier to determine.
At Fay Ranches, we have had the opportunity to list several of the best ranches on the market throughout the United States. This affords us a significant advantage and access to a larger sample of the ranch real estate market. In most cases, we can use the value bracketing method with numerous ranches from a broader region. Likewise, we have invested heavily in an extensive marketing platform that not only has a tremendous regional exposure but also features national and international marketing, unlike any other ranch real estate brokerage. We have been tracking relevant sales and the market direction for decades. We are continually looking to the future, anticipating an ever-changing market and drawing from experience, with a focus on delivering results. Whether it is the sale of the family farm or the acquisition of a legacy ranch for the family, we have the decades of experience to make it the best possible experience. To learn more about our reach, click here!
By Greg Fay, Founder, Broker September 2021, Volume 7 It’s early September 2021 on the Sunday of Labor Day weekend. I’m sitting on the porch at our ranch in Madison County, Montana. We’re baling our second cut of hay this week. I just took my two Llewelyn Setters for an upland bird hunt for Hungarian […]
By Kimberly Lowry, Broker Associate for Fay Ranches, Licensed in Montana The deep roots of the current Split Diamond Ranch registered Angus seed stock operation began somewhat humbly in the scenic Wise River corridor in the 1970s. Owner Steve Buckner fell in love with the stunning property at the base of “Eagle Rock,” adjacent to […]