Land Investor FeaturesVolume 4

Pricing Land

By Greg Fay, Founder/Broker, Fay Ranches & Jeff Boswell, Partner/Broker, Republic Ranches

How much should I ask? Who do I talk to?  What should my strategy be? 

One of the most challenging aspects of selling your land is knowing how to price it. The process of selling land is more often derailed by poor pricing strategy more than any other factor.  Pricing land is not an exact science. It is fraught with subjectivity and emotion, and therefore inaccuracy. And by inaccuracy, we mean overpricing.  In over 25 years of selling land, we can’t remember ever seeing land that was underpriced.   

In addition to our own observations, we interviewed several successful land brokers and sellers and asked them for their opinions on the proper process to price land accurately. We also asked their opinions on strategies that most often result in the highest sale price for your land. 

There was remarkable consistency in the comments we heard from both agents and sellers who had gone through the process of selling land.  First and foremost: find an honest, competent, and experienced land broker to help you value the land, and listen to them. There is nothing wrong with asking two or three recommended land brokers to provide a valuation. However, most landowners cannot help but fall into the trap of listing their land with the agent that gives them the highest valuation.  That agent is almost always your worst choice, for a couple of reasons.  The most successful agents will provide accurate valuations because they have enough business that they don’t need to ‘buy the listing.’  Those agents invest a substantial amount of time, effort, and money into marketing and selling the listing, so it is a waste of everyone’s time, effort, and money if the land does not sell. Inflating the recommended list price to get the listing is a common practice amongst real estate agents. Falling into that trap is like hiring the builder who gives you the lowest bid. This strategy almost always turns into a nightmare and ends up costing you more money in the long run. It is extremely difficult for a landowner to turn away the agent that provides the highest valuation. If you can do this, you will sell your ranch for more money.  

Real estate pricing 101 dictates that your land listing will never have as much interest as it does when you first put it on the market. You can only do this once.  If you don’t take full advantage of this initial offering period, you will likely have a long road ahead of you, and will ultimately sell your land for less money than if you had priced it accurately from the start.   

For land, this initial offer period is the first year the ranch is listed.  If you haven’t sold your land once it is over, you will inevitably enter a period of price reductions (if you still want to sell).    

During the first year, your land is listed and is new to the market, you have leverage as a seller if you have priced the land correctly.  Potential buyers will believe that they will have competition for buying your ranch. Further, buyers of ranches can fall in love with a place and let emotion help the seller keep the price up.  If they never come to see the ranch in the first place because it was overpriced, that opportunity is lost. If you have not correctly priced the ranch from the beginning, you may never have such leverage again, and it is the eventual buyer who will.   

At some point, your land will reach a price point at which the market decides it is a value.  At this point, you will likely only have one interested party, because you’re not getting many showings.  That potential buyer will lowball you.  If you’re not interested in selling at their price, they’ll just back off and wait, because time is on their side. 

You don’t get a ‘do-over.’  You’ll never get another chance to introduce your land to the market.  You can change the name of the listing, or change companies, but the market knows. This scenario plays itself out over and over in the land market.  We know several sellers who would love to go back in time and price their land accurately right out of the gate.  

Part of the reason land so often ends up overpriced is that most landowners (including us) feel that their land is the best land there is.  And for them, it is.  Land is a very personal and emotional asset for many people.  Every landowner can tell you why his/her land is better than his/her neighbors’ land.  This is what makes land wonderful, but it is also what skews our perception of value when it comes time to sell.   

 If you find yourself overpriced, one of the most common and weakest selling strategies a seller can have is refusing to lower the price but saying they will consider all offers.  Many times, these are otherwise accomplished businessmen and women who think this strategy is somehow in their best interest.  But instead, they’ve just taken away any leverage they may have had. You are always better off lowering the price and generating interest.    

The ranch market has changed substantially over the past 15 years.  Land Investors have more market information available to them and have become much more educated and, consequently, the need for accurate pricing has become more important.  

The bottom line: if your goal is to sell your land for the most money possible, you must put your emotions aside, and get advice from knowledgeable land agents. Resist listing with the company that may be providing an inflated value just to get the listing, and price your land accurately from the outset to take advantage of the leverage you have as a seller during the first few months you have it on the market. It will work out much better in the long run.

CONNECT WITH GREG FAYGreg Fay Real Estate Broker Founder Owner Headshot 2022

Greg Fay is a pioneer in the land brokerage industry. When Greg founded Fay Ranches in 1992, it was initially called Fay Fly Fishing Properties. Greg was the first to assign value to the recreational amenities of large agricultural ranches. He began marketing ranches on a national and international basis to a new audience, anticipating that there would be buyers who shared his recognition of placing value on the quality of the trout fishing or elk hunting on a given ranch—a paradigm shift in the market. Prior to Greg’s new approach, the value of a ranch in Montana was based primarily on its agricultural production.

GFay@fayranches.com | 406-586-4001

Upland Game Bird Hunting

By George Duke, Ranch Sales, Licensed in MT, WY This article is an exclusive preview from Land Investor magazine volume 8, coming November 2022. Upland game bird hunting in South-Central Montana is no longer a secret. The Clarks Fork of the Yellowstone River valley all the way down into Wyoming, and the surrounding Pryor mountains […]

How to Prepare For a Backcountry Trip

By JW Robinson, Agent, Licensed in WY This article is an exclusive preview from Land Investor magazine volume 8, coming November 2022. One of the largest attractions to the Western United States is the vast acreage of land allocated for public use, including large tracts of state land, National Forest, regions managed by the Bureau […]